Randy Newman “Little Criminals” (1977)

The more I listen to Randy Newman, the more I'm impressed. It's not his voice, even though his nasally vocal has a pleasant, relaxing quality. It's certainly not the music which on Little Criminals is particularly one paced with a soporific, dozy aspect. It's not even the lyrics. They can be incisive, biting and sardonic but they also are simple and endearing with a homey feel. No, it's none of that. What it is, is the subjects he choses to write about and the subtle twists he puts into the stories. Take the title track as a prime example. Start listening to "Little Criminals" and you have this picture of indigant locals determined to rid their town of a small-time drug dealer. But, as the song progresses, you suddenly realise his protagonists are themselves criminals worried about a newcomer taking away their business - or, even better, lowering the tone of the neighbourhood because they're into armed robbery and consider that a higher calling than drug dealing. Brilliant! Or how about "Rider In The Rain" which subverts the myth of the lone cowboy wandering the plains by reminding us of the wife he's abandoned and the fact he's "raped and pillaged" his way to the place he is now. Or "In Germany Before The War" which conjures up a picture of a old guy shutting up his store every day to wander down to the banks of the Rhine to gaze out over the river. Only this guy is (I think) Peter Kurten, a real-life serial killer, preying on defenceless children. And all that's without mentioning Newman's dig at psychiatry in "Sigmund Freud's Impersonation Of Albert Einstein In America" or how appearances can be deceptive with "Jolly Coppers On Parade". And another example of how satire can backfire in "Small People" which a great many people took offence to because they believed Newman was deadly serious. Although, thinking about it, I suppose it wasn't technically a backfire as the song became a massive hit! As you would expect there are a couple of tender love songs - "Kathleen (Catholicism Made Easy)" and "I'll Be Home". Plus the song "Baltimore" is particularly affecting as I visited the city very recently. I think there must have been a great deal of urban regeneration since that song was written because Newman's Baltimore is a far bleaker and darker place than I saw. I don't think Newman will ever release a classic album because of the way he writes. The uncertainty of the does he mean it? is he joking? is unsettling and uncomfortable and makes it impossible to like everything. But I'm equally convinced that, after hearing just two of his albums, there will always be something for me to enjoy on all his others. –Ian